Criticisms of the argument that women cannot be priests

Jesus certainly did not say so himself. Men are more goal-oriented, and women are more care-and-need-oriented. He also implies that women were not among the apostles at other crucial events, such as when, at the Last Supper, he commissioned them to celebrate the Eucharist and, before his ascension, when he instructed them to teach and baptise all nations.

We hope this gives an idea of what the Church would look like in their hands. God is One; God is Threefold. Here are some of them: In giving women such freedom and such an elevated place in their fellowship, they broke all of the customs of the day.

In theConstitutiones Apostolicae it is argued that it is not fitting that a woman baptize; it is considered wrong and foreign to the teaching of Christ.

Criticisms of the argument that women cannot be priests

A lot of religions today are still reinventing themselves to satisfy the changing worldview. Women may not touch sacred objects. Nowhere is the issue precisely about the maleness of Christ. Brown has made millions of dollars selling these books to women. The priest has to represent Christ in His humanity; it was a question of magisterial teaching, based on the Gospels and mediated by the Church through the hierarchy.

In the beginning, male dominance was the ultimate characteristic of marriages. That Da Vinci Code book makes us crazy.

Lastly, the distinctions made by canon law between ordinary and extraordinary ministers of baptism cc. Visit the Catholic Answers book and tract shop here. Among these we find: Men and woman are equal in the eyes of God, but this equality is not synonymous with sameness.

Also, considering the cultural restrictions of the time, was it really possible for Jesus to call women from the start in such a new undertaking. If all were a single organ, where would the body be. To subscribe to This Rock, go here. It will hurt, not help, women and it will do damage to all.

The press loves this group of radical feminists who buck the authority of the Church. But do these non-facts establish permanent norms in any way.

Criticism of the Catholic Church

The Eucharist is a great unifying symbol, and a tool to remember Jesus, but that's about all it is. MERGE already exists as an alternate of this question.

Does the minister of the sacraments represent Christ the Male or Christ the Mediator of saving grace. Scripture is not inerrant, and only parts of it are the Word of God, it should be read with a critical eye. Men usually have more distance from their emotions and evidence a tendency to detach themselves from immediate reactions whereas women tend to be more immediate and spontaneous in their responses.

The Church counters this argument with its claim that "Though it is true that sometimes it is lawful to tolerate a lesser moral evil in order to avoid a greater evil or in order to promote a greater good, it is never lawful, even for the gravest reasons, to do evil that good may come of it —in other words, to intend directly something which of its very nature contradicts the moral order, and which must therefore be judged unworthy of man, even though the intention is to protect or promote the welfare of an individual, of a family or of society in general.

Women in the Catholic Church If the Church rewrote the Bible to subvert the role of women, we doubt they would have confirmed the inclusion of the book of "Judith" at the Council of Trent in when the Protestants threw it out.

If all the other elements of the original appointment were apparently transitory, why would the masculinity of the early group constitute a permanent norm. They will go to the internal fire prepared for the devil and his angels Matthew 25,41unless before the end of their life they are received into the Church.

The formal element, surely, in the doctrine of the incarnation is that the Son of God became human. Religions that practiced class discrimination and ethnic discrimination, are reengineering their scriptures to make them acceptable. Second, in our culture when referred to as roles, these ministries of men and women are likely to be viewed in the terms of superior and inferior, of a dictatorial boss and of cowed subordinates.

Whether the female sex is impeded from receiving orders. Gay marriage is fine with this crowd. Now all of us feel no guilt at receiving is interest for loans.

Why Can't Women Be Priests?

Many of this crowd are quite open to Wicca as a viable spiritual path and think the Church should lighten up.

To be sure, the argument is unlikely to satisfy many Catholics or women outside the Church, who will always see the ban on female priests as an anachronistic means of defending male privilege.

The Question of Women Priests and the argument in Persona Christi by Eric Doyle OFM. the possibility of further dialogue arises at once. In a spirit of dialogue, then, I want to examine the argument against the ordination of women to the Hence it cannot.

In making the argument against women in Vatican roles during a trip to Turin, Latvian Lutheran Church rules that women cannot be ordained priests. Jun 10, 3 ways to. Among the greatest controversies in the Catholic Church is the question of the ordination of women.

The Church's teaching on this matter, however, cannot change. Why can't women be priests? In the Person of Christ the Head. At the most basic level, the answer to the question is simple: The New Testament priesthood is the priesthood of.

2. Wouldn't ordaining women take care of the vocations crisis? If the Church allowed the ordination of women, there could very well be more ordinations that take place. However, these wouldn't aid the Church because the ordinations wouldn't be valid.

Why can't women be Catholic Priests?

So, invalid ordinations are not the solution to the "vocations crisis" that we hear so much about. A Serious Argument Against the Ordination of Women to the Priesthood and Episcopate.

by The Rt. Rev.

Why can't women be Catholic Priests?

John Rodgers The designation of men to be priests or elders in the people of God is a wider expression of the headship the man is given first in the family. It will hurt, not help, women and it will do damage to allThe Rt. Rev. John.

Criticisms of the argument that women cannot be priests
Rated 4/5 based on 55 review
Criticism of the Catholic Church - Wikipedia